Perhaps e.l.f.’s most popular product (so much so that the brand’s iconic Stanley collab even included a holder for your favorite shade), the Glow Reviver Plumping Lip Oil set is the ultimate lip-loving beauty gift. (Pro tip: This is a great set to split up among friends.) Like the Glossy Lip Stain set above, you’ll find two fan-favorite shades — Burst Bubble and Ultraviolet — alongside two brand-new, exclusive ones; first, there’s Heavy Petal, a gorgeous shimmering peach, and next, Talk That Taupe, a sheer chocolatey beige.